SHOULD I BUY THE BLACKBERRY Q5?
Smartphone makers believe
in trickle-down economics. They build their portfolios top to bottom, looking
to get as much bang out of the flagship as they can and, after the hype around
it has settled, they bring out the more affordable packages to keep the cash
rolling in. The big question - always - is how much of the flagship specs will
trickle down the ranks.
Having delivered the latest
BlackBerry 10 OS in a classic messenger form factor, a midrange package
combining touchscreen with the iconic hardware keyboard was next on the
Canadians' to-do list. The Q10 came at a price not a lot of people can afford,
so the Q5 promises to deliver the same experience without sweeping the fluff
out of your pocket.
BlackBerry Q5
official photos
At first glance, the Q5 has
all the important checkboxes ticked. You get a dual-core Krait chipset, a
3.1" display of the same 720 x 720 pixel resolution and a four-row QWERTY
keyboard for that serious texting and emailing.
Key features
·
Quad-band GSM/GPRS/EDGE,
tri/quad-band UMTS/HSPA, 100 Mbps LTE
·
3.1" 16M-color 720p
(720 x 720 pixels) IPS LCD capacitive touchscreen
·
Four-row hardware QWERTY
keyboard
·
Dual-core 1.2 GHz Krait,
2GB RAM, Adreno 225
·
BlackBerry 10.1 OS; Office
document editor
·
BlackBerry Hub is a unified
inbox of all your communication and social networking accounts
·
BBM with video chat and
screen sharing
·
5 MP auto-focus camera with
face detection and Time Shift; LED flash
·
Full HD (1080p) video
recording at 30fps; 720p on the front-facing camera
·
2MP front facing camera
·
16GB of storage, microSD
card slot; Dropbox and Box.NET integration
·
Wi-Fi a/b/g/n, Wi-Fi
hotspot; Wi-Fi sync
·
Bluetooth 4.0
·
NFC
·
standard microUSB port,
microHDMI
·
3.5mm audio jack
·
GPS receiver with A-GPS
Main disadvantages
·
BlackBerry World is still
missing key apps
·
Screen size is somewhat
small by today's standards and the 1:1 aspect is awkward for video watching
·
QWERTY keyboard could be
better
·
BlackBerry Maps may be even
worse than Apple Maps
·
No FM radio
The screen is no longer AMOLED,
the camera has been downgraded from 8MP to 5MP and the CPU has been downclocked
by 300 MHz. These are things, which sure make the Q10 the more desirable
package, but not the kind that will dramatically change the user experience. It
looks like the BlackBerry Q5 is much closer to the BlackBerry Q10 than its name
suggests.
BlackBerry Q5 at ours
That, and the more
affordable price tag, may actually help the Q5 convince more users than its
bigger and more advanced sibling. We are about to see how much of that
potential translates in real-life performance. Join us on the next page, where
the Q5 gets unboxed and handled.
There's also a cheapish
looking headset and some leaflets in the package. A microSD card is missing but
the 8GB of internal memory should be enough as a start.
Design, build
quality and handling
The smartphone certainly
lacks the sophistication of the Q10 and even though the plastic used is of
decent quality, it's nowhere near as solid or good looking as on the Q10.
Cost-cutting was obviously not limited to the internals - the build and finish
were affected too.
Like all things BlackBerry,
the styling of the Q5 is respectful of tradition. The spaced-out QWERTY
keyboard takes after the Curves, as opposed to the tightly-packed, molded keys
of the Bold series - and the Q10. It's a cleaner, simpler design but not as
good looking. Quite unexpected for a BlackBerry handset, the back gives
slightly in when pressed harder, producing mild squeaks mostly around the
shared SIM/microSD slot. The flap covering the slot feels a bit flimsy itself.
Then again, it would be
unfair to the BlackBerry Q5 to only compare it to a clearly premium device like
the Q10, which is also one of the handsomest smartphones around. In more
general terms, the Q5 is average looking at the very least and certainly not a
smartphone you'd be embarrassed to be seen with.
The Q5 held
in hand
The phone's back is nicely
curved for comfortable handling. The finish is as good as immune against
fingerprints and provides for a great, secure grip. It is a well-built device
overall, except for the card slot flap.
QWERTY keyboard
The BlackBerry Q5 QWERTY
keyboard uses the same four-row layout as the one on the BlackBerry Q10, but
has the typical Curve styling, with slightly smaller but better spaced keys.
The keys themselves aren't
as pleasant to press on the BlackBerry Q5. They're sitting a little too low and
have a rather short stroke. They're almost flat too, compared to the sculpted
buttons on the Q10, which takes away some of the tactility and, in turn, the
speed and/or accuracy of typing. The company has chosen to stick with the
traditional numpad layout at one of the sides of the keyboard.
The keyboard
is decent but not perfect
The Q5 has more screen
bezel at the bottom - the BlackBerry logo is between the keyboard and the
display, rather than on top near the earpiece. That's one thing that works
better than on the Q10. When swiping up from the bottom of the screen, the Q10
doesn't provide a comfortable starting point, while the Q5 does.
The best thing about the
BlackBerry Q5 keyboard is that, just like on the Q10, it works with the
touchscreen, rather than being at odds with it. With plenty of shortcuts
available, most of which should be familiar to experienced BlackBerry users,
the keyboard can seriously speed up getting around the interface.
Instant Actions makes the
right kind of difference too, letting you launch apps and perform tasks using
search as you type interface. But we'll look at that in more detail in the
software part of this review - for now we'll just say that the Q5 is a fine
texting device, even if slightly worse than the Q10.
Controls
Now let's explore the rest
of the BlackBerry Q5 controls. Above the screen, we find the traditional status
LED, proximity sensor and the earpiece. The front facing camera on the Q5 is a
2MP unit that can do 720p video.
The earpiece
is flanked by the front-facing camera and some sensors
The right side of the
BlackBerry Q5 features the volume controls, with a small pause/mute button
squeezed in between. The convenience key, a token of the old days, is gone
along with the trackpad and call buttons.
The three key
combo on the right
The left side of the
handset is where the two slots, for SIM and microSD cards, are located. Those
are hidden under a small plastic flap which isn't really perfectly designed as
it got stuck a couple of times under the back panel and we had to push hard
against the back of the BlackBerry Q5 to release it. The other element of
interest on the left is the microUSB port, which is left exposed.
The microUSB
port is joined by a couple of port on the left
The 3.5mm audio port and
the power/lock key are at the top of the BlackBerry Q5, flanking the secondary
microphone.
The power
key, the secondary microphone and the audio jack sit on top
The bottom houses the
loudspeaker grille and the mouthpiece. It's an unusual position for a speaker
but one that makes sure you doesn't get muffled when the phone's resting on its
back. Not sure about pockets though.
The primary
microphone and the loudspeaker
The 5 megapixel camera lens
and a LED flash are the main attraction at the back. We like the fact that all
the mandatory labels such as the FCC ID are printed on a sticker than you can
remove, so it doesn't spoil the looks of the back.
The 5MP
camera lens and the LED flash are the stars backstage
Unfortunately, the back
panel of the BlackBerry Q5 is non-removable, meaning you don't get access to
the 2,180 mAh battery.
The good news is the
BlackBerry Q5 scored a very nice 55-hour endurance rating in our real-life
battery test. The small screen and the energy-efficient chipset must be getting
the credit for the solid performance.